Why Payroll Log Review Is a Compensating Control
Short answer
B The CISO adopted log and audit-trail review as a compensating control because payroll segregation of duties cannot be staffed.
Question
Key Takeaways
The trap is classifying the log-review activity by its daily operational nature instead of by its purpose of substituting for an infeasible primary control.
This CS0-003 question tests control classification by intent: when segregation of duties in payroll cannot be staffed, log and audit-trail review is implemented as a compensating control (B).
Common mistake: Option C, operational controls, is tempting because reviewing logs and maintaining audit trails are day-to-day human activities, but that describes the mechanism, not the reason the control was adopted.
Expert Analysis
The governing principle
Security controls are classified by why they are adopted, not by the mechanism they use. A compensating control is an alternative safeguard put in place when the primary, preferred control is infeasible, too costly, or otherwise cannot reduce risk to an acceptable level; the organization must still document the substitute and show that the original control remains desirable. That intent-based classification is the deciding rule in CS0-003 scenarios that pair a business constraint with a substitute measure.
Applying it to payroll
The primary control here is segregation of duties in payroll: splitting authorization, processing and review so one person cannot both create and approve a payment. The stated constraint is staffing — the small company cannot assign enough people to keep those roles separate, so the primary control is infeasible rather than merely overlooked. The CISO's response, maintaining and reviewing logs and audit trails so improper payroll activity becomes detectable after the fact, substitutes detective visibility for preventive separation. Because it is chosen specifically to offset that infeasible primary control, option B, compensating controls, is the correct classification. Several comments land on B for exactly this reasoning: an alternative measure adopted when segregation of duties is not feasible.
Why the alternatives fail
Option C, operational controls, describes how the safeguard is carried out — log review and audit-trail maintenance are daily human activities, which is why one comment places logging under operational and argues the CISO is merely compensating for staff rather than implementing compensating controls. That reasoning confuses mechanism with purpose: the question asks what the CISO implemented in response to a constraint, and intent decides the label. Option A, corrective controls, restore a system after an incident; no restoration occurs here. Option D, administrative controls, are policies and management directives — a written segregation-of-duties policy would not create the missing headcount.
What to carry forward
Whenever a stem says the ideal control cannot be done and names a substitute, the substitute is a compensating control regardless of whether it looks administrative, technical or operational in daily practice.
Official Reference
https://www.comptia.org/certifications/cybersecurity-analyst
This link opens the official vendor documentation in a new tab.
Exam Strategy
Read the stem for two signals: a primary control that the organization explicitly cannot perform, and a substitute measure. The inability clause forces the compensating-control answer no matter what technology the substitute uses. Then check the remaining options against their definitions — corrective restores after an incident, administrative is policy or management directive, operational is routine human activity — and eliminate any option that only describes how the substitute is performed, since purpose outranks mechanism in control-type questions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a control compensating rather than operational?
Why is reviewing logs and audit trails not the best answer here?
Could segregation of duties be fixed another way in this scenario?
Community Votes
50% of anonymous learners picked answer C. Votes are pick records left by other test-takers — they are not the verified answer.
Discussion 4 contributions
Compiled from public community threads and reader submissions, lightly edited for clarity. Handles and vote tallies are shown as recorded, and comments reflect the views of individual contributors.
From public community threads 4
-
glenndexter 👍 7 Answered BThe Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) implemented: B. Compensating controls. Compensating controls are alternative measures put in place when primary controls are not feasible or sufficient to mitigate risks adequately. In this scenario, due to staffing limitations, the small company cannot effectively segregate duties to prevent errors and fraud in payroll management. Therefore, the CISO chose to implement compensating controls by maintaining and reviewing logs and audit trails. These controls help mitigate the risk of errors and fraud by providing oversight and accountability, even in the absence of traditional segregation of duties.
-
Nishaw 👍 3 Answered BB. Compensating controls Explanation: Compensating controls are alternative measures put in place when primary controls are deemed insufficient. In this case, the lack of segregation of duties is compensated for by maintaining and reviewing logs and audit trails to mitigate the risk of error and fraud in payroll management.
-
MrPeps 👍 1 Answered COperational controls are security measures performed by people as part of an organization's daily operations to protect systems and monitor security. Examples include: Reviewing system logs. Monitoring security events. Maintaining audit trails. Performing regular security checks. Monitoring user activities.
-
ffc7bdf 👍 1 Answered CC. The while the CISO is compensating for lack of personnel they are not implementing compensating controls. Logging and audit trails would align with operational controls.
Reader comments & corrections
No reader corrections yet — spotted an error or have a note? Share it below.