Suspicious Email Legitimacy: Headers and SPF, DKIM, DMARC
Short answer
BF Review the forwarded email's headers and verify SPF, DKIM, and DMARC results from the original message to determine the suspicious email's legitimacy.
Question
Key Takeaways
It tests header-based email authentication analysis, and the main trap is choosing gateway spam scores (A) or SMTP HELO/EHLO data (E) instead of evidence from the suspicious message itself.
This CS0-003 email-analysis question tests how to verify a suspicious message's legitimacy; the correct actions are reviewing the forwarded email headers and checking SPF, DKIM, and DMARC on the original email (B, F).
Common mistake: The most plausible wrong answer is A: SCL and BCL are useful spam-filter triage scores, but they are platform-specific gateway signals and do not validate the sender domain, message integrity, or policy alignment the way original-message SPF, DKIM, and DMARC do.
Expert Analysis
The direct evidence is in the message headers
The analyst is asked to judge the legitimacy of a suspicious email, so the strongest evidence is what travels with the message and can be verified against the sender domain. Option B is correct because reviewing headers from the forwarded email can reveal the Received chain, Return-Path, Message-ID, Reply-To, and any Authentication-Results. Comments on the item split between A/F and B/F, but the B/F reasoning is the one consistent with header analysis: the header review shows routing and spoofing clues, while the authentication fields give concrete pass/fail evidence.
SPF, DKIM, and DMARC answer a different question
Option F is also correct because SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email test three distinct things: SPF authorizes the sending IP for the domain, DKIM checks whether the signed content was altered, and DMARC aligns those results with the From domain and applies policy. Looking only at the forwarded envelope or the visible recipient is not enough. The word original matters: if the forwarded copy stripped the original headers, the analyst must obtain the original message or its headers; otherwise F cannot be performed reliably.
Why the attractive alternatives miss
Option A is the most tempting distractor, and comments argue that SCL and BCL are useful. They are useful triage scores, but they are gateway/platform-specific spam indicators, not sender-authentication evidence, and they do not prove legitimacy. Option E is SMTP-session data (HELO/EHLO) that would require server logs, not the delivered message. Option C merely confirms who received it, which the analyst already knows, and Option D describes MIME structure, not provenance.
What would change the answer
If the scenario said the analyst has only mail-gateway logs and no original message, E could become relevant for tracing the connecting server. If the question asked which gateway scores help prioritize spam, A would be adjacent. But for determining legitimacy from a suspicious email, B and F are the defensible pair. Getting this wrong operationally means either trusting a spoofed message because the visible From looked right, or dismissing a legitimate message because a forwarded copy failed authentication after rewriting.
Official Reference
- https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7208
- https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6376
- https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7489
These links open the official vendor documentation in a new tab.
Exam Strategy
On email-legitimacy questions, separate evidence that travels with the message from data that only exists elsewhere. If an option names a header field (Received, Authentication-Results, SPF/DKIM/DMARC), it is usually the analyst's direct evidence; if it names gateway scoring or SMTP session logs, ask whether that artifact is actually available from the suspicious email. For multi-select, pick the two options that inspect the original message's provenance and authentication, not just the visible sender or recipient fields.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is option B correct when the email was forwarded?
Why not choose SCL and BCL for this question?
When would HELO or EHLO be useful in email analysis?
Community Votes
50% of anonymous learners picked answer F. Votes are pick records left by other test-takers — they are not the verified answer.
Discussion 32 contributions
Compiled from public community threads and reader submissions, lightly edited for clarity. Handles and vote tallies are shown as recorded, and comments reflect the views of individual contributors.
From public community threads 30 of 32
-
kmordalv 👍 22Correct Review the headers from the forwarded email: Examining the email headers can provide crucial information about the email's source, path, and any intermediaries it went through. This information can help identify signs of spoofing or suspicious behavior. Examine the SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email: These three mechanisms (Sender Policy Framework - SPF, DomainKeys Identified Mail - DKIM, and Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance - DMARC) are used to authenticate the sender's domain and reduce the likelihood of email spoofing. Checking these fields can provide insights into the authenticity of the email.
-
greatsparta 👍 18I think B is a bit of a trick as reviewing the "forwarded" email headers would not provide accurate details of the original path. (unless it is forwarded as an attachment with the original email)
-
TurboMor 👍 12ChatGPT is going to make you fail hehe... if you review the headers of the "forwarded" email, you are going to look at the details of the forwarded email, not the malicious email.
-
bmadajczyk 👍 9If you are 'lucky' one of the first to be attacked by a phishing campaign, scoring will tell you nothing unfortunately.
-
throughthefray 👍 7Tough one I really really liked B except for the fact that forwarded emails no longer contain the headers of the original sender. The headers are replaced with the forwarders info. gonna have to go AF for this one.
Show 25 more comments
-
hashed_pony 👍 5Forwarded emails DO NOT have headers on the original email. AF is correct. Source: I'm already an analyst and I've seen this multiple times.
-
Kamel_ 👍 5As for someone who works in the SOC, we take a look at "BF" first.
-
RiccardoBellitto 👍 4Guys, as a SOC analyst we review the headers and I knowing how CompTIA say things unclearly, I think the "Forwarded" email referee the "Forwarding Email IOC" where, according to the CompTIA Study Guide provided by Dion Training: Forwarding ▪ When a phishing email is formatted to appear as if it has come as part of a reply or forward chain So, I'm going with BF
-
madx411 👍 4you dont review forwarded email but email sent to you as attachment., so B is wrong.
-
luiiizsoares 👍 3Correct Answers: B. Review the headers from the forwarded email F. Examine the SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email Analysis: Review the headers from the forwarded email (B): Email headers contain important metadata, such as the sender’s IP address, email servers involved, and the path taken by the email. Reviewing headers helps in identifying spoofed addresses and abnormal routing paths. Examine the SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email (F): These fields help validate the authenticity of the email. SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance) are email authentication protocols used to verify that the email was indeed sent from the claimed domain and was not altered in transit.
-
BanesTech 👍 3The answer is B,F. While the forwarded email may not include the complete set of original headers, it often includes headers indicating the path the email took from the sender to the recipient. These headers can still provide insights into the email's origin, intermediate servers it passed through, and other relevant information for assessing its legitimacy and security implications.
-
SH_ 👍 3Answer is AF. Note that when an email is forwarded, the headers of the original email are not included. So I'll go with AF.
-
muvisan 👍 3vote for AF. Why not B - according to comptia, forwarded emails don't include original headers,
-
deeden 👍 3I vote BF because scoring may vary especially for newly emerging threats or zero-days.
-
kmordalv 👍 2After reviewing the question I believe the correct answers would be A and F. F without any doubt. Regarding answer A, the BCL value is added to the message in an X-header and is similar to the spam confidence level (SCL) that's used to identify messages as spam and The Spam Confidence Level (SCL) is a value from 0 to 9 assigned to a message that indicates the likelihood that the message is spam.
-
robizman 👍 2BF. • These are email authentication mechanisms: • SPF (Sender Policy Framework): Verifies the sender's IP is authorized to send on behalf of the domain. • DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail): Ensures the email content hasn't been tampered with. DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance): Aligns SPF and DKIM results and provides policy enforcement.
-
DARKVEGETA 👍 2Threat Analyst here. AF is correct. We are talking about a forwarded email. When my team get a spearphishing email we ALWAYS ask for the original email to be saved and sent to us so we can look at the headers. Forwarded emails will not have that information.
-
Robuste7 👍 2I mean, why should we focus on the forwarded email? Because every time an email is forwarded, the new email creates a new envelop. That means we won't be able to see the old header,
-
f90ecff 👍 2Chat GPT picked B until I pointed out that it was a forwarded email. Great catch — yes, the fact that it’s a forwarded email does matter and can change how useful the headers are.
-
chaddman 👍 2Review the headers from the forwarded email: Headers from a forwarded email can sometimes be altered or incomplete, making them less reliable for analysis.
-
friendlyneighborhoodITguy 👍 2ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Microsoft Copilot - B and F.
-
CyberJackal 👍 2B&F imo.
-
section8santa 👍 1E. Evaluate the HELO or EHLO string of the connecting email server: The HELO or EHLO string is part of the SMTP (Simple Mail Transfer Protocol) session initiation and can provide information about the email server that initiated the connection. By examining this string, the analyst can determine if the server is a known or expected sender, which can be a critical factor in assessing the email’s legitimacy. F. Examine the SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email: SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) are email authentication methods that help prevent email spoofing. Analyzing these fields in the email header can help the analyst determine if the email genuinely originated from the stated domain or if it’s a spoofed email.
-
SKETCH_ 👍 1Evaluate scoring fields: Email security gateways assign scores like Spam Confidence Level (SCL) to indicate the likelihood that a message is spam. A high score suggests the email is illegitimate and should be treated with caution. Review email headers: Analyzing the headers allows an analyst to check if the email passed DMARC, SPF, and DKIM checks. This confirms if the sender is authorized to send mail on behalf of the domain and helps identify "typosquatting" or spoofing attempts
-
Comicbookman 👍 1The two best options for determining the legitimacy of a suspicious email are: Evaluate scoring fields, such as Spam Confidence Level and Bulk Complaint Level (A) – These scores help determine if an email is likely spam or phishing based on predefined filters and reports. Examine the SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email (F) – These authentication mechanisms verify whether the email was sent from an authorized source and ensure its integrity.
-
ffc7bdf 👍 1AF, are the only options that will provide information related to the specific email in question. Analyst will view the SPF,DKIM, etc but the tooling which digs into the email would provide some scoring of confidence against known IOCs. Why even use this source if youre just gonna GPT everything
-
7167087 👍 1I think the key here is the assumption of a forwarded email. Forwarded email headers already cannot be useful for analysis, and still you have to focus on addressing the question. A is a general, direct answer of the question, while B is operating on assumptions not addressed in the question.
-
Wutan 👍 1Very nicely caught. The answer fooled me too. The header from the forwarded email would not contribute to the analysis.
-
zecomeia_007 👍 1B. Review the headers from the forwarded email F. Examine the SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email
-
2cedd62 👍 1A. Evaluate scoring fields F. Examine SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fields from the original email, GPT !!
Reader comments & corrections
No reader corrections yet — spotted an error or have a note? Share it below.