Handling Non-Firmed Planned Orders in D365 SCM
Short answer
B Set the planned order to Completed to mark it as finalized without firming it, preserving it for reference.
Question
What should you recommend?
Key Takeaways
The trap is confusing 'Approved' with 'Completed'; Approved prepares an order for firming, while Completed finalizes it without firming.
Learn how to manage planned orders that will not be firmed in Dynamics 365 Supply Chain Management. The correct action is to set the status to Completed.
Common mistake: Choosing 'Approved' (Option D) because it seems more 'permanent' or 'respected' by the system. However, Approved is a step towards firming, whereas the requirement is explicitly NOT to firm.
Expert Analysis
The core of this question lies in understanding the lifecycle and status semantics of Planned Orders in Dynamics 365 Supply Chain Management's Master Planning engine. The scenario presents a specific constraint: the orders must not be firmed, yet they need to remain available for future reference against any manual orders that might be created.
The most attractive but incorrect answer is D (Change the status to Approved). This option sounds right because 'Approved' implies a level of validation and persistence. In fact, comments highlight that 'Approved' planned orders are respected by master planning and protected from modification during a master planning run. However, the key distinction is that an 'Approved' status is a precursor to firming; it signals readiness for conversion into a firm purchase or production order. If the business explicitly states they do not intend to firm these orders, setting them as 'Approved' misrepresents their intent and leaves them in a state that suggests pending action rather than closure. Furthermore, while Approved orders persist, they are technically part of the active planning pool, which contradicts the goal of simply rejecting the plan without converting it.
The correct approach is B (Set the planned order to Completed). According to Microsoft’s official documentation on maintaining planned orders, if you decide not to firm a planned order, you should give it a status of Completed. This status marks the order as finalized without triggering the firming process. It effectively rejects the planned transaction while keeping the record intact for historical or reference purposes, such as comparing against subsequent manual orders. Unlike 'Unprocessed' or 'Deleted', 'Completed' preserves the data lineage. Unlike 'Approved', it does not signal readiness for firming. Therefore, 'Completed' is the precise semantic fit for 'planned but not firmed'.
Official Reference
This link opens the official vendor documentation in a new tab.
Exam Strategy
When dealing with status-based questions in Master Planning, always map the status to its functional outcome: 'Approved' means ready for conversion/firming, while 'Completed' means rejected/finalized without conversion. Check the verb in the requirement ('firm' vs 'reject') to select the correct status. Do not assume 'more permanent' equals 'correct'; look for the specific definition in the vendor docs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens to a Planned Order with 'Completed' status?
Why not delete the Planned Order instead?
Community Votes
50% of anonymous learners picked answer D. Votes are pick records left by other test-takers — they are not the verified answer.
Discussion 12 contributions
Compiled from public community threads and reader submissions, lightly edited for clarity. Handles and vote tallies are shown as recorded, and comments reflect the views of individual contributors.
From public community threads 12
-
IlseKH 👍 3 Answered Di would say approved, because completed is treated like unprocessed and will be deleted in the next MRP run, so you cannot compare any manual orders against it.. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dynamics365/supply-chain/master-planning/planning-optimization/approved-planned-order#view-and-edit-the-status-of-planned-orders
-
Kev_Sharp 👍 3 Answered BThe intention is to not firm the orders. "If you decide not to firm a planned order, you can give it a status of Completed." https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dynamics365/supply-chain/master-planning/maintain-planned-orders#planned-order-status
-
AntoonvM 👍 3if you do not want a planned order to be firmed it can be set on completed and that means it is rejected. Approved is one step toward firming.
-
Calvin_Zhou 👍 3Should be D? Status with Approved cannot be changed.
-
E_tech07 👍 2Yes, it should be Approved and not completed. If you decide not to firm a planned order, you can give it a status of Completed. If you want to firm a planned order, you can change the status to Approved. Planned orders with Approved status are respected by master planning, so they are not modified or deleted during a later master planning run. To achieve this, the planning logic copies the Approved planned orders from the old plan version to the new plan version during master planning.
Show 7 more comments
-
Saeidkajkolah 👍 2The case says it won’t be firmed so Completed is correct.
-
Saeidkajkolah 👍 2C. Approve means it is firmed. The company won’t firm.
-
Saeidkajkolah 👍 2Sorry. I meant B; completed
-
David92400 👍 2So good answere is D.
-
Gemami 👍 1 Answered DD. Change the status to Approved. The case explicitly says: Planned orders that will not be firmed must not be changed. Adventure Works wants to be able to reference the planned orders later against any manual orders created. Although Completed is the documented status for orders you decide not to firm, Approved is the status that protects planned orders from being modified or deleted by subsequent planning runs. Also, Approved does not mean Firmed. Firming is a separate action that converts the planned order into an actual order.
-
globeearth 👍 1 Answered BB. Set the planned order to Completed. - Changing the status to "Completed" (e.g., via Planned orders > Maintain > Change status) marks the order as finalized without firming it into an actual order. Why not D. Change the status to Approved ? -> - Setting the status to "Approved" indicates the planned order is ready for firming or further action.
-
6caf793 👍 1Correct answer is B! In the planned orders form, if you hover over the status see: Completed – planned purchase or works orders that you have processed but have not approved for firming.
Reader comments & corrections
No reader corrections yet — spotted an error or have a note? Share it below.