Where to Place an AVD Host Pool for Per-User Access Pricing
Short answer
D To isolate per-user access pricing for the Fabrikam users and avoid charging licensed internal users, first add a new host pool to a new subscription.
Question
The tenant contains user accounts for all internal users and users from a partner company named Fabrikam, Inc. Each internal user is assigned a Microsoft 365 E5 license. The users at Fabrikam are not assigned any licenses.
Sub1 has an Azure Virtual Desktop deployment that contains a host pool named Pool1. Pool1 contains a RemoteApp named App1.
You need to configure access to App1. The solution must meet the following requirements:
• The Fabrikam users must be licensed by using Per-user access pricing.
• App1 must be accessible to all the internal and Fabrikam users.
• Costs must be minimized.
What should you do first?
Key Takeaways
It tests that per-user access pricing is a subscription-level setting, so mixing licensed internal users and unlicensed external users in Sub1 can trigger charges for everyone; the trap is jumping straight to application-group assignment.
This AZ-140 question tests how Azure Virtual Desktop per-user access pricing applies to unlicensed Fabrikam users, and the correct first step is D: place the external host pool in a separate subscription.
Common mistake: The most plausible wrong answer is A: adding Fabrikam users to the App1 application group appears to grant access, but it ignores subscription-level pricing and would make internal E5 users cost extra.
Expert Analysis
Why option A is tempting Option A seems to satisfy the most visible requirement: adding Fabrikam users to the application group that contains App1 directly grants them access to the RemoteApp. In a basic AVD deployment, application-group membership is indeed how you publish access to internal and external users, so A looks like the obvious first move.
Where A stops being correct The missing constraint is per-user access pricing. Per-user access pricing is enabled at the Azure subscription level for the host pool subscription, not by application-group assignment. If you enable it on Sub1 to license Fabrikam, the charge applies to users accessing AVD resources in that subscription, including internal users who already have Microsoft 365 E5. Because costs must be minimized, Microsoft recommends a separate subscription for external users so licensed internal users are not double-charged.
What to do first Option D is the first structural step: add a new host pool in a new subscription dedicated to the Fabrikam external users. Once that subscription and host pool exist, enable per-user access pricing there, deploy or publish App1, and assign Fabrikam users to the new application group. Option B keeps the external workload in Sub1 and does not isolate the pricing scope. Option C assigns F3 licenses and neither uses per-user access pricing nor minimizes cost.
Addressing the common objection A comment notes that a new host pool would not automatically contain App1. That is true, but the question asks what to do first to meet the licensing and cost requirements; publishing App1 in the new host pool is a later configuration step, not a reason to keep unlicensed external users in Sub1.
Official Reference
- https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/virtual-desktop/licensing
- https://docs.azure.cn/en-us/virtual-desktop/licensing#per-user-access-pricing-for-external-commercial-purposes-to-use-azure-virtual-desktop
These links open the official vendor documentation in a new tab.
Exam Strategy
When an AZ-140 question mixes eligible internal licenses with external per-user pricing, check the scope of the licensing control before choosing the visible access step. Application-group membership grants access, but subscription-level per-user pricing can charge every user in that subscription. If the stem says costs must be minimized and internal users already have E5 licenses, separate the external host pool into a new subscription first, then publish the app and assign Fabrikam users there.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does per-user access pricing apply only to Fabrikam users in Sub1?
Why not just assign Fabrikam users to the App1 application group?
Can Microsoft 365 F3 licenses replace per-user access pricing for Fabrikam?
Community Votes
50% of anonymous learners picked answer D. Votes are pick records left by other test-takers — they are not the verified answer.
Discussion 10 contributions
Compiled from public community threads and reader submissions, lightly edited for clarity. Handles and vote tallies are shown as recorded, and comments reflect the views of individual contributors.
From public community threads 10
-
jeff1988 👍 6 Answered ATo meet the requirements of licensing Fabrikam users with Per-user access pricing and ensuring that App1 is accessible to both internal and Fabrikam users while minimizing costs, you should first add the Fabrikam users to the application group that contains App1. This step ensures that the users have access to the application. So, the correct answer is: A. Add the Fabrikam users to the application group that contains App1
-
Bonesurfer 👍 3Correct Answer is A To meet all the requirements, including minimizing costs, add the Fabrikam users to the application group that contains App1. This will provide them access through per-user access pricing without incurring additional license or infrastructure costs.
-
sKostas 👍 3 Answered DThe per-user license need to be configured at the subscription level. The subscription is already having users with E5 license so you will need to create another subscription.
-
RayH 👍 2 Answered DI vote for D, https://docs.azure.cn/en-us/virtual-desktop/licensing#per-user-access-pricing-for-external-commercial-purposes-to-use-azure-virtual-desktop "Azure Virtual Desktop also charges users with separate assigned licenses that otherwise entitle them to Azure Virtual Desktop access. If you have internal users you're purchasing eligible licenses for, we recommend you give them access to Azure Virtual Desktop through a separate subscription that isn't enrolled in per-user access pricing to avoid effectively paying twice for those users."
-
AITANA_MANAGEMENT 👍 2No, that answer is incorrect and could confuse people. Microsoft recommends that external users be licensed in a separate subscription as a best practice. You would be right if it weren’t for the fact that option D includes the following: "Add a new host pool." With this, you would no longer have access to app1 because it would be in the other host pool, which automatically eliminates option D. However, I insist that the part about creating a new subscription for external users is correct.
Show 5 more comments
-
Darkphoenix126 👍 2 Answered AAccording to Copilot: First thing you should do is A. Add the Fabrikam users to the application group that contains App1. By doing this, you can then configure the necessary licensing for the Fabrikam users under per-user access pricing. This approach ensures that both internal and external users can access App1 without creating new host pools or increasing unnecessary costs.
-
Bonifacef 👍 2 Answered Aanswer is A
-
Ivanvazovv 👍 1To minimize costs a separate subscription IS required. Otherwise even internal, licensed users would pay additionally for the access they already have. This is from the official MS documentation: "Azure Virtual Desktop also charges users with separate assigned licenses that otherwise entitle them to Azure Virtual Desktop access. If you have internal users you're purchasing eligible licenses for, we recommend you give them access to Azure Virtual Desktop through a separate subscription that isn't enrolled in per-user access pricing to avoid effectively paying twice for those users."
-
Ivanvazovv 👍 1"Costs must be minimized". This means a separate subscription IS required. Otherwise even internal, licensed users would be charged additionally for accessing the AVD solution.
-
RV3472 👍 1 Answered DNew subscription is needed to activate per-user licensing
Reader comments & corrections
No reader corrections yet — spotted an error or have a note? Share it below.
Related Analysis
Practice All AZ-140 Questions
Access 64 questions with complete answers and detailed explanations.
View Full AZ-140 Practice Test →